"I am not someone who takes time with surveys or writing reviews.

However, I had the opportunity to witness first hand how one of my close friends Auto and Home Insurance was handled by Sheeley Insurance Agency, Inc. (Located in Milford, Pa.)

After several policy issues and challenges with their carrier, my friends were fortunate having John Hollister at their side. His skill set and thorough understanding of the insurance industry quickly resolved any issues.

My personal Auto policy was recently coming to term and i decided to give Sheeley Insurance an opportunity in providing me with a quote. John took the time to acquaint me with alternatives and options in a clear and precise manner. He not only beat my current policy cost, but three others a well. I also found John's follow-up and communication simply unparalleled.

Having had years of experience dealing in business development and customer relations, I found it refreshing knowing John's ethics, integrity and professionalism continue to be an element to his success while remaining truly focused on his customers. Thank you John!"


"Sheeley Insurance makes you feel more like a customer rather than a number. They make insurance easy to understand which has given our family peace of mind so that we can enjoy our home, vehicles and lives. They make the claims process as painless and easy as possible. After I hit a deer, I immediately got a rental car and my car was fixed within a week!"

Doug Malefyt

"I just wanted to take a minute and say thank you to you and your team. Chris and I really appreciate everyone at Sheeley Insurance as well as Safeco for the quick and hassle free service.

As you know a deer smashed into the side of my car a little over a week ago and did some costly damage to the vehicle. We called right away and the representative was quick to handle the claim, which was impressive because it was a Sunday. The rental car was set up for me right away and I was able to make it to and from work on time. The body shop gave an estimate and in a little over a week the check arrived in my mailbox.

Hopefully the repairs to my car can be finished up soon and I'll be back on the road. Thanks again for everything!"

Stephanie & Chris Roushinko

"Sheeley Insurance is one of our most valued business partners. From managing our annual business insurance renewal, to helping us through our recovery from extensive property damage, to counseling us when our members have experienced medical emergencies, Sheeley Insurance always has our best interests in mind. Chris Lord and the entire team are readily available, fast to respond, and always thinking ahead for us. You don't know how much you need the right insurance agency until you really need one, and Sheeley Insurance will be there for you."

Barry Klein - Elevations Health Club

"I want to thank you for making me understand that my current workers comp and commercial insurance carrier was costing my company a substantially large yearly premium. You were considerate and patient with my questions. I would highly recommend Brian to anyone who is in need of an honest and professional insurance agent who is deeply committed to his clients."

Joyce - Castle Shannon Learning Center

"I have insured my home through Sheeley Insurance and my agent has always been Nancy Erhardt. She has been my agent for 14 years. She is knowledgeable, efficient, and helpful in every way, but most importantly I consider her a personal friend, and for me I can give no higher recommendation than that."

Dr. Frederic Koehler Sutter

"This insurance company is EXCELLENT! It's a 5G network-"Great service, great prices, great staff, great communication, great friendship! Thanks Brian!!!"

Jodie - Noah's Ark Child Center

"I had always sorted my own insurance using the internet and comparing all the 'discount' companies and thought that was better than using an agent. I came to John at Sheeley Insurance because I had some unusual insurance needs to do with building my new house. He solved the complex issues but it quickly became clear that it was easier, more comprehensive and less expensive to just give John everything which I have now done. My only regret is I wish I had done it a lot earlier. He and Emily are a terrific team and I'd strongly recommend them to anyone."
Justyn Comer

"In the 7 years since I moved here to Milford, I have had such wonderful support , expert care and comfort dealing with John and have recommended several of my friends to your office. You're definitely my only 'go to' for all my insurance needs and I wish you all the best."

Claire C.

"Sheeley Insurance really works hard for you to find the best insurance options available, regardless of the carrier. They provide clear recommendations on coverage tailored to your needs so that you aren't paying for things that don't fit your situation."

Tim M


Want to ask an actual client? Talk to one of these daycare providers and see what they have to say about us!

Castle Shannon Learning Center
Castle Shannon, PA
Contact: Joyce

Aa to Zz Childcare and Learning Centers
Harrisburg, PA
Contact: Ryan or Ashleigh

Tender Years, Inc.
Camp Hill, PA
Contact: Jay

Children’s Family Center, Inc
Mechanicsburg, PA
Contact: Denise


Stroudsburg, PA
518 Sarah Street
Stroudsburg, PA 18360
Voice: 570-421-1191
Fax: 570-421-1617
Dunmore, PA
146 Chestnut Street
Dunmore, PA 18512
Voice: 570-342-9121
Fax: 570-880-7725
Honesdale, PA
918 Church Street
Honesdale, PA 18431
Voice: 570-253-2634
Fax: 570-253-3593
Milford, PA
106 Broad Street
Milford, PA 18337
Voice: 570-296-5588
Fax: 570-796-0070

©Copyright 2019 Sheeley Insurance Agency | Privacy Policy

Website by WebLeaps