Sheeley Insurance wins National Partner of the Year Award!

Thursday, October 5th, 2017


Keystone Insurers Group (Keystone) awarded Sheeley Insurance Agency (Sheeley) of Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania, its highest honor – National Partner of the Year – on Sept. 19 at Keystone’s national conference in Charlotte, North Carolina. The announcement was made by Keystone President & CEO David Boedker and Sheeley principal John Hollister.

The award recognizes the agency that best exemplifies Keystone’s mission: “Independence works better together.” Criteria include demonstrating a commitment to grow through leadership mentoring, engaging in technology advancements, employing best practices to improve operations and developing new income streams to strengthen their business diversity.

Sheeley Insurance Agency is Keystone Insurers Group’s 1st “National Partner of the Year” out of 10 State winners



Sheeley was one of 10 state winners nominated for the honor. The other nine ‘State Partners of the Year’ included:

Hollister explained the extensive work that led the agency to winning the national award and the real reason his agency is part of Keystone.

“We’ve spent a lot of time on staffing,” he said. “Our ultimate goal is to have all staff understand they are a critical part of the ‘machine’ and that their actions have positive and negative consequences. But it is our fellow Keystone partners that are the best resource. We’ve made a lot of close friends and generated the ability to talk about ideas, struggles, coverage issues and management/staffing issues. Within the partnership, we can be honest if we’re struggling with something, and you don’t often get to do that in business anywhere else.”

“Keystone partners are of the highest caliber of independent agencies in the country,” noted Boedker. “Sheeley Insurance Agency embodies everything that is extraordinary of the elite – constantly seeking new ways to develop talent and facing the numerous challenges of our industry with an intrepid spirit. We are beyond excited to acknowledge Sheeley’s outstanding performance with the inaugural ‘National Partner of the Year’ award.”

About Sheeley Insurance Agency – Sheeley is an independent insurance agency with four offices throughout eastern Pennsylvania. As a Keystone partner, the agency is committed to providing its clients national resources sourced locally. Learn more at

About Keystone Insurers Group – Keystone started in 1983 when four independent insurance agencies teamed up to pool their experience and expertise. Determined and scrappy in the face of a difficult market, this small group believed that agencies could be stronger and more successful if they linked arms — a passion and spirit that continues. Growing to almost 300 independent agency partners in 11 states, Keystone provides its agents with a community of like-minded agencies, industry expertise and access to specialized products for their clients. Keystone is ranked number three on Insurance Journal’s 2017 list of Top 20 Privately-Held Property/Casualty Agency Partnerships. For more information, go to



Leave a Reply


Stroudsburg, PA
518 Sarah Street
Stroudsburg, PA 18360
Voice: 570-421-1191
Fax: 570-421-1617
Dunmore, PA
146 Chestnut Street
Dunmore, PA 18512
Voice: 570-342-9121
Fax: 570-880-7725
Honesdale, PA
918 Church Street
Honesdale, PA 18431
Voice: 570-253-2634
Fax: 570-253-3593
Milford, PA
106 Broad Street
Milford, PA 18337
Voice: 570-296-5588
Fax: 570-796-0070

©Copyright 2019 Sheeley Insurance Agency | Privacy Policy

Website by WebLeaps